Several months ago, I published a sentence with a parenthetical in it:
"You can't market your way out of a mess (but you can use marketing to lead the way)."
The first half of that statement – which to be honest, came out of my mouth on a whim and stuck because I saw how people responded to it – is easy to agree with. Anyone who has watched an organization try to message its way past a broken process or a battered culture knows it's true. But the parenthetical is where I hid what I think is the more interesting claim, and I never came back to explain how it really works. I listed what marketing-that-leads would look like: a signal about what's possible, a public commitment that creates accountability, a framework for building the reality you're claiming. But then I stopped – plenty of claims, and not much proof.
And now I want to talk about what the parenthetical looks like when it actually works – in studios run by founders who came to me with strong convictions but not the words to go along with them.
Here's the short version of what this is about: marketing leads the way when it starts with who an organization is genuinely working to become. Not something invented because it sounds good, and not just slapping decoration and bling on something that’s mediocre. But rather, the real goods – dug up, written down, and used. The rest of this essay is that sentence, unpacked: what the digging looks like and where it starts.
Two recent engagements are worth sharing together here, because their stories ran on the same track. Both are studios in the design field – one architecture, one interiors. Both led by women who left their corporate firm jobs, where they were principals, to start their own practice – specifically because they wanted to run it how they wanted to run it. (I can relate.)
They work in different markets, have different teams – and their vibes are distinctly different from one another.
But both had built businesses that genuinely operate differently from their competitors. Not just claimed differentiation, but the real deal: clear decisions about who they work with (and don’t), what kind of work they do (and won’t do), their social impact goals, how they treat the people around them, where they refuse to compromise. Strongly held convictions lived daily, in the work itself.
While these convictions showed up easily in their behavior and beliefs, they didn’t yet have the right words to use outwardly.
Their websites could have belonged to anyone in their field. Their proposals said all the usual things, in all the usual order, because they'd never found another way to say them. They were mimicking what they’d seen everyone else do – which is both normal and common.
Most marketing advice assumes the hard part is becoming different, but these founders had already done the hard part. They were different. What they didn't have was the language – the plain, written-down version of who they are and importantly, what they stand for – presented in a way that someone else could read and recognize.
So the work we did together wasn't about invention – it was more like excavation. In both cases, the goods were already there, just not in plain sight, and that distinction mattered for everything that came after.
So what does the digging actually involve?
It starts with a rule I hold onto, and it's as much a rule for me as for my clients: I won't put fancy words on a business if there's no there, there.
If a company's only difference is the marketing – if the way they operate and what they value looks like everyone else's – then no amount of good writing will help, and they're better off spending their money elsewhere. That's not me being noble. It's just that words can't convincingly describe a position that doesn't exist.
Which is why these two engagements were easy to say yes to from the start. There was no grasping at straws to figure out what’s actually unique about these people and their businesses. The essence existed, but the articulation didn't.
Most founders already know who they are. They can't always say it, because the knowledge lives in hundreds of small decisions they've made over the years, not in a messaging document – but it's in there. They just haven't had someone to do the excavation with.
The coolest thing about writing it down is that the act itself can change what the convictions are. And it can also make them more strongly held because it gives them real shape, and a defined purpose that feels like it’s worth sharing with the world.
Something that stays too implicit can drift. You can hold a value loosely for years, and it bends a little each time a deadline or a difficult client pushes on it – and no one, including you, really notices. But something explicit is different. Once it's in writing – plain words, your name on it, other people able to read it – it becomes a commitment. A standard you can be measured against, by your clients and your team, and by yourself.
For founders with strong integrity, this is the part that matters most. Getting it down on paper isn't the reward at the end of the work. It is part of the commitment.
So here's how the digging actually goes.
Four moves, roughly in order – though like most real work, they overlap and double back on each other.
Their words first, mine second.
Before I write a single line of anyone's marketing, I ask questions. A long up-front survey and a longer conversation: why the business exists beyond making money, what's non-negotiable, how they want to be seen, what they're done tolerating from their industry. In their own words, unpolished.
The reason is simple: I'm not in the business of just making up words for someone else's business. The essence is already in there – it lives in the decisions they've made, and it comes out in bits and pieces constantly. My job is to mine for it, recognize it, gather it up, and hand it back to them assembled. Both surveys from the two clients I’m referencing here were, in fact, full of GOLD – phrases I would never have thought to write but immediately recognized as theirs.
Say it plainly.
Then comes the assembly. All that gathered material gets distilled into language that anyone – a prospective client, a future hire, a community partner – could read and recognize: who they're for, what they stand for, why it matters. No blustery adjectives doing the heavy lifting. No industry jargon (that one’s a hard habit for everyone to break, including me at times).
The test isn't whether it sounds impressive. It's whether the client reads it and says some version of: Yes. That's what I've been trying to say.
Break it into pillars.
Paragraphs can inspire, but they can't steer the loads of small decisions we all face every day. So the essence gets broken into three or four pillars – convictions specific enough to answer real questions. Not "integrity," which nobody's against. Things like: the kind of work we'll take and the kind we won't. Who our work serves. What we believe about how the work should get done.
When a decision shows up – a bad-fit client, a proposal that doesn't sit right – the pillars give the founder something to check against besides mood and deadline pressure.
Wire it into the ongoing work.
This is the move everyone skips, and it's where coherence is won or lost. Words drift back toward mush unless they get used. So for both studios, the writing became a working rule for everything that came after: every project story or thought leadership piece answers to the pillars. This can sound rigid, but it’s not meant to restrict or constrict. It’s meant to ground and direct, and honestly to keep things more simple.
None of this is complicated. There's no proprietary trick in it. Most of it is just having the discipline to find what’s already in there, and then actually use it.
One more thing, because it would be strange to leave it out: I didn't dig my own words up by myself either. A while back, I had to admit my own business was running on the same setup – strong convictions, lived daily, but the language part was flailing and unclear. So I did what my clients do. I found someone to ask me the questions I was too close to ask myself.
I’m telling you this for a practical reason. The excavation method isn’t easier when it’s your own business – it’s actually harder. Your convictions hide in plain sight, and you’ve built up a lifetime of reasons why they can’t be put plainly. An outside set of questions cuts through that.
It felt weird for me to admit that the thing I do for other people was so hard to do for myself, but honestly – that’s just the way it goes. Cobbler’s children have no shoes, and all.
Most marketing advice starts with words: find your message, sharpen your story, say it louder.
But the whole thing is much more effective when the substance comes first. These two founders who had spent years standing for something – making decisions about what they want their impact to be, and what they will and won't do, long before anyone was watching or asking. The words didn't create any of that. They drew from it. All the digging did was give their convictions a shape they could share – and in the sharing, a standard they could keep owning, and building on.
That's the way this work holds up. When the words draw from something real, something different, something you actually stand for – they don't drift back toward mush, because there's a solid foundation holding it all together. And a business like that doesn't have to perform its difference. Its marketing just becomes what it already is: a description of a real, bold thing.
If this resonated, I write one essay a month on purpose, strategy, and the work of building organizations that match their ambition. Get it in your inbox.